You are the owner of this article.
featured

As Montana begins training new community health workers, Haiti may offer a window to the state’s health-care future

  • 0
  • 17 min to read

In late 2017, Montana legislators voted to substantially cut funding for mental health care, in response to a budget shortfall. Some of the effects on the state’s mental health system were immediate: Mental health centers in Livingston, Libby and elsewhere closed or contracted, leaving many, especially in rural Montana, stranded without care. Other services may be lost or weakened over time.

In the rural U.S., around 60 percent of residents already live in areas with a dearth of mental health professionals. The problem is particularly acute in the vast lands that make up the rural West. Most of Montana is ranked as a mental health shortage area by the Health Resources & Data Administration; in Glendive, Montana, for example, a single psychiatrist offers services on a part time basis. At the same time, Montana has higher-than-average rates of mental illness and suicide.

In the wake of the budget cuts, a group of newsrooms spanning western and central Montana, in collaboration with High Country News and the Solutions Journalism Network, explored how communities are responding to prevent the state’s mental health crisis from worsening. It’s our second project in The Montana Gap initiative, focused on the resilience of rural communities — and on the growing divide between those towns and the state’s growing urban centers.

+6 
feat-MontanaGap-LOGO.jpg

What we found was a rise in informal treatment options: Rather than replacing the mental health workers whose jobs disappeared, communities are building on-the-ground care networks. In Anaconda, for example, trainers teach residents how to identify a friend or stranger facing potential mental health crisis and how to intervene. In Choteau, extension agents train teens on how to treat their mental health as they would physical health, with simple first aid tactics. Across the state, people who have struggled with addiction or mental health issues can become professional peer supporters.

The idea of mental health support that goes beyond psychiatric help is not new: The communities we live in have always played a role in keeping us healthy and happy. Formal and professional interventions have lived alongside cultural mechanisms that, by design or not, help keep people's mental state on track, from counseling by religious leaders to the familiarity and companionship of book groups or coffee klatches.

But those traditional supports often skirt the underlying problems. People often find it hard to talk about mental illness, and a 1997 study found that the stigma around mental health increases as the size of the community shrinks. Informal care can draw in members of the community who may previously have passed their neighbors, unaware of their struggles or unable to find ways to relate to them effectively.

Still, the shift in rural Montana raises the question: Is this a promising shift in mental healthcare or a sign of a woefully inadequate system that’s kicking its problems down the road? In other words, do these relationship-based interventions serve the purpose just as well, and offer a glimpse of the future of mental health treatment? Or are they a bandage on a bigger structural problem?

Our stories begin to address that question, examining the data on what works and what doesn’t. But that’s just the beginning: We hope this series will help bring the challenge of mental health in Montana out from the shadows — and inform a statewide conversation about what a successful mental healthcare system could look like.

Kate Schimel

Deputy editor-digital

High Country News


As a child, Presandieu Charles suffered severe headaches and stomach pains. One day he beat his mother on the foot and thigh with a stick, and later cried when he saw what he had done.

In October 2017, Charles began to hammer at the timber walls of his family’s dirt-floored home with his fists. He would not stop. Neighbors bound his ankles and wrists with leather straps and metal chains. They called his affliction “the madness.” He still has the scars: dark star-shaped marks on the skin on his right wrist.

The house perches on the edge of a lush, forested ridge several miles outside Cange, a remote Haitian village near the Dominican border. Inside it is cool, and slivers of light stream through the white lace curtain hanging in the front door frame. Charles’ shoulders droop as he sits on a bed dressed with Pokémon sheets. The 24-year-old wears an Adidas t-shirt and plastic Nike sandals. Beside him is Joseph Benissois, a local community health worker with the Boston-based global health nonprofit Partners in Health (known in Haitian Creole as Zanmi Lasante). The two exchange no small talk, and Benissois begins to ask Charles questions from a clipboard in his lap. Charles doesn’t often smile as Benissois asks them. When he does, though, it’s a sweet, knowing flash of pride at the progress his answers reveal.

Does he cry? Not as often as he used to.

+6 
feat-i28cover.jpg

Does he have difficulty sleeping? No, but he feels weak when he wakes, and he has trouble going to the garden or fetching water. That might be the drugs he is taking.

Does he feel bad or uncomfortable with himself? In the past he felt bad. Now he tells jokes to the friends he sees on the street, smiles and laughs with them.

In the past 15 days, has he wanted to die? “He used to say to himself that it’s better if he died, but not now,” an interpreter relays.

Partners in Health, which was founded just down the road in Cange by renowned physician and humanitarian Paul Farmer, has been recruiting and training individuals like Benissois since the late 1980s and placing them on the frontlines of the organization’s efforts to combat cholera, HIV and other major health threats. But the 2010 earthquake that devastated this rugged Caribbean nation — killing an estimated 220,000 people, injuring more than 300,000 more and leaving some 1.5 million homeless — brought to the forefront another widespread Haitian health risk: This country of more than 10 million people had only 10 psychiatrists. The loss of homes, jobs and loved ones in the quake triggered a rash of depression that Haiti’s few specialists, already struggling to treat a host of other mental-health issues, were ill-equipped to handle. In the central plateau, Partners in Health tasked its community health workers (CHWs) to help fill the gap in mental-health coverage.

The questions Benissois asks Charles come from a depression symptom inventory developed by the nonprofit. They’re identical to those asked by its 58 other mental-health-focused CHWs. Since April 1987, Benissois has worked with the organization as a CHW (or accompagnateur in Creole), a non-specialist position designed to provide patient check-ups and administer basic health care in small, remote communities. The model traces its roots back to the mid-1950s and China’s so-called barefoot doctors: farmers and other villagers who received short-term medical training to meet immediate needs in isolated towns. Gradually embraced and refined by the global health community over subsequent decades, the model is now a vital component of health-care strategies in scores of developing nations, and is being increasingly implemented in the United States. In fact, after five years of coordinated development by various stakeholders, Montana recently rolled out a CHW training curriculum of its own to support statewide implementation of a model that the Montana Office of Rural Health/Area Health Education Council says is proven to increase health-care access, reduce costs and improve responsiveness to patient needs. That the timing of that roll-out coincides with state budget cuts and widespread layoffs among community-based health-care service providers is entirely coincidental.

+6 
feat-MirebalaisRooftops4.jpg

The city of Mirebalais, on Haiti’s central plateau, is home to a state-of-the-art hospital and houses the Haitian headquarters of health-care nonprofit Partners In Health.

Benissois is a familiar face in the hills around Cange, having served as the local pastor and a community advocate for more than 30 years. He visits as many as 20 patients a month throughout the Cange and nearby LaHoye regions. Occasionally, he’ll take a moto — a motorcycle taxi, one of the more popular modes of transportation in Haiti — to visit people like Charles. Today he’s on foot, shuffling with a lopsided gait along the shoulder of the highway, smiling casually to those he passes and greeting them with a familiar “bonjour.”

Benissois visits Charles once a month. While Charles keeps regular appointments with Partners in Health physician Reginald Fils Aime in Cange, and is currently taking antipsychotic medications, the at-home check-ups with a trusted neighbor free him from having to make extra trips — a mile walk each way — to the clinic. When asked what the veteran CHW has done to help him, Charles wraps an arm around Benissois and beams.

“I love him so much,” Charles says. “He is my father and Jesus Christ.”

That Montana, an isolated, largely rural state nearly 3,000 miles from Haiti and, geographically, nearly 14 times the size, has recently embraced the CHW model in the face of its own health-care challenges makes the organization’s decades of work a compelling case study. Though culturally distinct, the two areas share many commonalities: remote populations, impoverished communities and, particularly in the wake of last year’s cuts to Montana’s mental-health budget, a pressing need for local solutions. And if the benefit that Benissois delivers to Charles is any indication, CHWs could become a valuable asset for Montanans as well.


The Partners In Health headquarters resides in a huge state-of-the-art hospital in Mirebalais, about a half-hour drive southwest of Cange. On what has become a typical morning there, hundreds of Haitians crowd onto wooden benches inside. More spill out of the entryways into the tropical sun. Some sleep on blankets or cardboard in the shade of bushes planted along the hospital’s white walls. A young woman strolls toward the exit, a newborn in her arms and a gaggle of friends skipping behind her, shouting excitedly, “She’s a mom!”

In a cramped office upstairs, Père Eddy Eustache, director of mental health, speaks in crisp, undulating English about why his organization opted to address the needs of this mountainous region with community health workers in the first place.

+6 
feat-i28-screenshot-2.jpg

In this screengrab from a 2017 PBS NewsHour segment, members of a pilot project at Mountain-Pacific Quality Health talk to Kalispell patient David Dixon about managing his health conditions.

“When Zanmi-Lasante brought this community-based approach, the main goal was to bridge the rural area to the urban one,” Eustache says. “To bridge the destitute to the privileged people. And how can you do that without representatives of these neglected, these outsider people? And we came to find ... this person, men or women, first of all must be living in his or her community of belonging. Physically present. Sharing the daily life of the people. Almost of the same condition.”

Similarly, in a June 2016 report on health-care innovation and reform, Gov. Steve Bullock’s administration cited CHWs’ double roles as frontline care providers and community liaisons as a compelling reason for embracing the CHW model. According to the Montana Healthcare Workforce Advisory Committee, 15 of the state’s 56 counties contained no licensed social workers in 2017. Thirty-one counties lacked licensed clinical psychologists, and 40 lacked psychiatrists.

CHWs have been implemented by various nonprofit providers throughout the state for years. Researchers often refer to the practice of transferring non-specialist duties to lightly trained community members as “task-sharing,” an approach that increases accessibility for patients while decreasing reliance on faraway specialists and urgent-care centers. However, unlike states with robust government-supported CHW programs, including Oregon, Minnesota and New Mexico, official sanctioning via certification or training hasn’t come to Montana. Until now.

This June, five state-affiliated area health education centers launched Montana’s first-ever online training course for community health workers. Developed over a two-year period with the help of a $140,772 grant from the Montana Healthcare Foundation, the new standardized curriculum is open to anyone with a high school diploma and designed to prepare individuals for engagement in “various activities including outreach, community education, informal counseling, social support and advocacy depending on the needs of the employing facility/organization.” Kris Juliar, director of the Montana Office of Rural Health & Area Health Education Center in Bozeman, says Montana CHWs will operate as component parts of broader health-care teams. While she anticipates growing interest in the position, Juliar cautions that it may take some time to see CHWs in action in Montana.

“We’re trying to be really careful about not training people for jobs that don’t exist,” she says. “The job market for community health workers is really in its infancy in Montana. There’s definitely some opportunities out there, but if I trained you to be a community health worker, could you go out and find a job in that? Right now I think it’d be difficult.”

Mental health is not a primary focus of the training yet, but Juliar says that MHN is already developing additional training material for CHWs tailored to that need.

With a fledgling CHW presence now in the offing here, Partners in Health’s work in Haiti offers a window into a possible future of health care in Montana. Partners in Health has gradually grown its cadre of mental health-focused CHWs from 28 to 59, serving an area that encompasses the country’s central plateau and neighboring lower Artibonite region. Drawing on a new round of donations, the organization is currently in the process of raising that number to 81. ZL/PIH’s community health workers receive one week of in-person training — about half the length of the 85-hour online course in Montana — covering the basics of physical health, ethics, communication skills, sanitation and detection of infectious diseases. CHW candidates focusing primarily on mental health are also trained in depression screening and how to deal with patients displaying psychosis, agitation, epilepsy and suicidal ideation. They do not diagnose, but are able to refer patients to more specialized care if needed. Eustache does not see CHWs as representatives of the organization, despite the financial incentives they receive. Instead, he says, people like Benissois are advocates for their own communities, people who must be above political and moral suspicion, not only trusted by patients, but able to spur local community leaders, religious leaders and traditional healers to bring about change in public attitudes toward mental health.

“Here, for instance, people say if I hit you as a crazy person, you need to hit me back, otherwise you’ll get mentally sick as well,” Eustache says. “There’s another aspect of stigma. It’s underlining, for instance, the total impossibility for someone to recover 100 percent from mental illness. They’ll say who got crazy once was always that crazy. Can you see how solid it is, a belief that is tied to stigma?”

+6 
feat-BenssoisPresandieu4.jpg

Joseph Benissois, a community health worker in Cange, stands next to Presandieu Charles, on whom he’s been checking up monthly to gauge Charles’ mental health.

For Montana, the obvious question becomes one of efficacy. A 2007 policy report by the World Health Organization warned that the failure of numerous CHW programs worldwide due to poor planning and underestimation of the effort required to execute them has “unnecessarily undermined and damaged the credibility of the CHW concept.” The effectiveness of CHWs across the globe has been the subject of considerable research in recent decades. Those studies have focused on CHW work on a variety of health conditions — tuberculosis, HIV, diabetes — as well as their integration into more robust health teams made up of various specialists and lay caregivers. One such study, conducted in Zaire, found that over a two-year period in the late 1990s, 65 percent of malaria cases in 12 villages were treated by CHWs and documented a 50 percent decrease in morbidity compared to a control area with a single health center with no CHWs. Many of these studies have been conducted at project sites in poverty-stricken countries, and among the most commonly cited deficiencies in the body of CHW research is the need for greater focus on the longer-term results of CHW application.

“Without data across years, researchers cannot look at global trends and progress made over time,” the Frontline Health Workers Coalition, a global alliance of healthcare NGOs, wrote in a 2014 report on the need to improve CHW data. “Further, lack of data on CHWs prevents CHWs and their supporters from being able to effectively advocate in the policy arena.”

Research on CHW programs in the United States is even less robust. A 2007 Community Health Worker National Workforce Study compiled by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services estimated there were 121,206 CHWs employed nationwide — a 41 percent increase over 2000. However, the study, the only one of its kind the agency has published to date, offered the caveat that there is “no statistical evidence, of the size and direction of change in the community health worker workforce.” Papers that have been published indicate that wider use of CHWs holds promise for increased access to and utilization of health care. A 2016 study in the Journal of General Internal Medicine found that in most cases involving chronic conditions like diabetes, asthma and hypertension, CHW interventions drove down patient costs and reduced hospitalizations and urgent care visits. On the mental health front in particular, a 2018 review of literature by several California-based researchers found that CHWs could, domestically, be mobilized to serve as primary providers of evidence-based treatments in areas with “severe workforce shortages,” and even be involved in the delivery of those treatments in more resource-rich settings. “CHW-delivered prevention and early intervention services would allow trained mental health professionals to focus their expertise on individuals who require more intensive services,” the study continued, though the authors cautioned that additional research is needed to understand how to sustain CHW-centric efforts.

In Montana, the project launched in 2015 has repeatedly cited the potential for CHWs to engage in community education and outreach, informal counseling and the linking of medical and social services as reasons to not only develop a standardized training curriculum, but to establish mechanisms for data collection and continued discussion among various individuals, organizations and state agencies. And based on six years of fieldwork and research in Haiti’s central plateau, Bonnie Kaiser, a postdoctoral fellow at the Duke Global Health Institute, agrees that community health workers like those employed by ZL/PIH could similarly benefit rural Montana when it comes to mental health access and treatment.

+6 
feat-PereEddy1.jpg

Père Eddy Eustache, left, mental health director for Partners In Health in Haiti, discusses the benefits that community health workers have brought to the region’s remote residents.

“Reaching people in the communities they live in is a much more successful model for actually linking to care,” Kaiser says. “And having it be people who are trusted community members when it’s an issue that can be really stigmatized is really important, because it’s the kind of thing people might not seek care for a number of reasons. But they’d be fine chatting to a friend or neighbor, because that just feels a little bit safer and less stigmatizing than saying, ‘I’m going to a psychiatrist.’”


Two months ago, the boys played like children do, clambering around a ruined building just down the lush green hillside from their home. Now their mom, Moslene, cooks only for her husband, a mechanical act that brings her no joy. Only sadness and a remembrance of the innocent laughter she will never hear again. Her boys — her only children — are dead. A wall of that ruined building fell on them, killing them instantly.

Moslene’s house, a one-story, two-room concrete structure with a wrap-around porch and faded blue and white paint, is noiseless in the muggy morning heat. Her husband is down in the garden. He’s always in the garden. Not long ago, he spoke of drinking poison.

Moslene sits sideways on a high-backed chair beneath the fruit trees in her small dirt yard, her shoulder pressed against the dark wood, legs drawn up and crossed at the ankles. She wipes at her tears with the hem of her shirt and speaks in short snatches of Haitian Creole, just a few words at a time. Benissois does not touch or console her. He does not smile. He asks her questions from a list on a clipboard in his lap, his voice a deep, uninflected baritone.

Does she cry often? Yes. When she sees the other children walking to school, or hears them playing nearby. “Almost every day.”

Does she have difficulty sleeping? The suffering is not as bad at night. But sometimes she dreams. “She sees them in her dreams, playing, playing, and she knows this is not right,” our translator relays.

Does she feel bad or uncomfortable with herself? She doesn’t eat, doesn’t feel like herself. “She’s trying to remove this remembrance in her mind, but she can’t.”

In the past 15 days, has she wanted to die? “She prefers to die in the place of her sons, but that’s life.”

Benissois has been checking up on Moslene and her husband every two weeks since their sons, 8 and 10, died. Benissois has already referred her to a psychiatrist at the ZL/PIH clinic in Cange. She has an appointment in six days, her second since the accident. When he’s finished with the questions, Benissois reviews relaxation methods with Moslene, shaking his arms, massaging his thighs with his palms, inhaling through his nose and exhaling through his mouth. Moslene listens but does not participate. As Benissois rises to leave, she gathers up chairs, then retreats through a side door into her darkened home.

Benissois’ work with Charles, Moslene and others in the Cange area is a prime example of how CHWs can serve to redistribute the pressure normally placed on health-care specialists and the places they work. Yes, Charles receives treatment from Dr. Fils Aime. But his gradual recovery within his village is largely left to Benissois to monitor.

Adding CHWs to Haiti’s health-care equation has proven promising enough that ZL/PIH has exported the model to project sites in Rwanda, Malawi, Sierra Leone and Chiapas, Mexico. Eustache notes that there’s “huge enthusiasm” across the globe today about the work being done by CHWs. However, he cautions that such programs need to be community-driven, and that a CHW’s first loyalty must first be to their communities.

On the Navajo Nation, they’re known as community health representatives. Isolation is as big a hurdle here as anywhere in the western United States, with tribal members scattered across 27,000 square miles of New Mexico, Arizona and Utah. When the program launched with the help of federal funding in 1968, the vision was essentially identical to that in Haiti and elsewhere: Train and task trusted locals to staff health-care’s frontlines. Now the Navajo program operates with a $6.5 million annual budget and employs more than 70 community workers. In 2009, the Navajo Nation partnered with several organizations including Partners in Health to form the nonprofit Community Outreach & Patient Empowerment (COPE). A community health rep’s duties can range from taking vital signs and helping people get follow-up appointments with specialists to assessing home weatherization and educating people about outbreaks like West Nile virus.

“You’ll have one CHR that might be overseeing a community that has about 200 community members [and] one CHR overseeing a community that has close to 4,000 individuals,” says COPE Community Outreach Manager Olivia Muskett.

But if the Navajo Nation’s CHR program offers Montana a glimpse of anything, it’s what 50 years of evolution can lead to. Since the early 1990s, the program has required that CHR applicants possess a Certified Nursing Assistant Certificate, a qualification that takes, on average, four to eight weeks to acquire and is beyond what Montana’s new training currently requires. Muskett says the requirement is a reflection of how integrated CHRs have become in the Navajo Nation’s health-care system. COPE has also in recent years begun organizing monthly trainings and case-management meetings to strengthen relationships between CHRs and hospital-based providers.

Despite the decades, CHR training on the Navajo Nation has only recently started to tackle mental health issues head-on. All CHRs were sent through a mental-health first-aid course a couple of years ago, Muskett says, in response to increased rates of suicide in several of the places they serve. A few have been specifically assigned to mental-health teams, but PIH and the tribal health department are still discussing how to better incorporate mental health into community-health work, including adding lessons about cognitive behavioral therapy. According to a 2015 policy report by the University of Arizona, only 31 percent of CHR programs on Indian reservations in the U.S. reported focusing on behavioral or mental health, though 60 percent of those programs stated that their CHRs could benefit from formal training in substance abuse, behavioral health and lifestyle coaching.

“If you’re talking to community members about diabetes or their chronic illness, then you should include in that conversation the mental health issue that is associated,” Muskett says. “The individual is dealing with their illness, and of course they’re going to have some emotional tie to that and some mental tie to that.”

+6 
Haiti_1212_MirebalaisAerials_rollins_072.JPG

The Hôpital Universitaire de Mirebalais in Haiti was erected after the 2010 earthquake to deliver health care throughout the country’s central plateau. Contributors to the effort included the American Red Cross and Artists for Haiti, an organization co-founded by actor Ben Stiller.

As with research elsewhere, studies on the Navajo Nation frequently cite familiarity with local values, beliefs and social dynamics — and the consequent ability to build patient trust — as among a CHR’s strongest assets. Like Benissois in Haiti, community-based health workers the world over know all too well the social, financial and geographic challenges that those suffering from mental-health issues face. As Eustache says, CHRs are “sharing the daily life of the people.” It’s no different in Montana.

Take this story, from a June 2017 PBS NewsHour segment on a team-based health-care pilot project run by Mountain-Pacific Quality Health in Kalispell: Following a disabling motorcycle accident, Flathead Valley resident David Dixon had been grappling with chronic pain, nausea and episodes of depression for years. His visits to the emergency room were frequent — as many as 42 visits in 14 months. The pilot team, including community health worker Jane Emmert, succeeded in connecting Dixon with a pain specialist, and with tele-pharmacy services to sort out his various medications. Requests to MPQH for more information went unanswered, but Juliar says the outcomes she’s seen from the project show substantial health-care savings and decreased reliance on urgent-care facilities.

“People are not using emergency rooms as much,” Juliar says of patients involved with the pilot project. “Their health is better and they’re handling their health-care situation better. And the personal outcomes of the individuals — they’re feeling that they’re much more in control of their situation.”

Back in Haiti, ask Benissois why he does this work and you’ll get a shrug. His mustache will curl up at the corners. He will tell you it is his “pleasure” to help people. Then he will continue along the bustling roadside in silence, as if that’s answer enough.

Eustache’s response is almost equally succinct: “Money can be a motivating factor,” he says. “But you may find as well people who want to be more active and more supportive to their community and very sensitized to their community progress.”

Perhaps, as CHW training begins in Montana, Benissois’ smile and Eustache’s altruism offer some hint at who here will step up to help.


This story has been supported by the Solutions Journalism Network, a nonprofit organization dedicated to rigorous and compelling reporting about responses to social problems. SolutionsJournalism.org.

This story was updated on July 13 to correct an error regarding when Montana legislators voted to cut funding for mental health care.

Staff Reporter

Alex Sakariassen began working at the Indy in early 2009. He primarily reports on state politics, the environment and the craft beer industry. His work has appeared in the Los Angeles Times, the Choteau Acantha and Britain’s Brewery History Journal.

Load comments